"Translates beautifully to paneled storytelling...accessible in a way that denser comics aren't."
—Kirkus Reviews
"[Meaghan Tosi's artwork] Like autumn itself, it provides warmth and entertainment, but still has a darker side that can give chills."
—Manchester Ink Link
"Illustrator Meaghan Tosi’s artwork includes gleeful, comically expressive faces along with campy B-movie posters (a highlight being the Spanish-language version of The Aztec Mummy vs. the Cat People)."
—Kirkus Reviews
"The black-and-white line drawings by Meaghan Tosi...are delightful, featuring images that employ the same humorous exaggeration and mock-serious tone that pervade the text."
—Kirkus Reviews
"Meaghan Tosi's cartoon-like black-and-white line drawing illustrations punctuate the chapters with movement and humor, emphasizing the characters' emotions and focusing readers' attention on empathy for others."
—The Children's Book Review